Research aims
The overarching theme of this study is to examine how knowledge about racial diversity is constructed in early childhood education and how these practices contribute can to the theoretical development of racial literacy in the pedagogical discourse.
Theoretical framework
The theoretical impetus stems from Basil Bernstein’s pedagogic theory, the sociology of knowledge in combination with critical racial literacy perspectives (Bernstein, 2000; Epstein & Schieble, 2019). A curriculum theory perspective is applied to the research design, data production, analysis, and findings. Bernstein’s theory is applied to analysis of social and racial diversity in the pedagogic discourse (Bernstein, 2000). The pedagogic discourse includes the content of learning, how it is relayed and the regulation of the social order. The intersections of racial knowledge, identity, and belongingness are examined as knowledge negotiated in ordinary everyday pedagogical activities with young children.
Methods
This is an ethnographic study of early childhood education and care (ECEC). Participant observations were carried out at three different sites for a period of 21 days and a total of 70 hours of observations at each site. The data production consists of field notes and teacher interviews. This data has been analyzed with the aid of NVIVO software program for qualitative data.
Results
The results indicate a predominance of instructional strategies within competence models and modes in ECEC. Performance models and modes do exist but are much more infrequent and sparsely inserted into an overall tendency towards the competence model and liberal/progressive mode. Both models promote social diversity and social integration in the instructional discourse but do so in two distinct and separate ways. Competence models and modes utilize social difference as a knowledge source and as a means of learning about different kinds of learning objectives. In the competence model diversity is apparent in both the learning objective and in the transmission of knowledge. Performance models on the other hand downplay or underutilize difference and variations of the acquirers. Difference and diversity of acquirers’ comprehension is not utilized as a resource. Performance models can include knowledge about diversity by this is relayed to the acquirer with more explicit control, uniform and restricted transmission. Competence models promote social integration by way of knowledge and experiential learning of diversity as a social practice. Performance models tend to convey knowledge about social diversity, but without diversification of the transmission and acquisition of the knowledge process. The results also indicate that knowledge about racial diversity can on the one hand de-center normative whiteness while working to strengthen and build solid, secure, positive racial identifications with oneself and others, but on the hand other also reify and reinstate racialized group identities.
Relevance to Nordic education
Sweden and Scandinavian preschools are at the forefront of social integration. Preschool is the first step into the educational system and one of the first meeting spaces for newly arrived children and families. This study highlights and emphasizes the necessity of knowledge about racial diversity and diversification of pedagogical practices that can not only sustain, but also utilize racial difference and diversity as unifying force and source of inspiration for knowledge development.
2023.
Early Childhood Education and Care (ECEC), social integration, curriculum theory, diversification
The Nordic Educational Research Association (NERA) Conference 2023, Oslo Metropolitan University, Norway, 15-17 March 2023