The aim of this essay is to explain how IR theory relates to the European Union. This is motivated by the extensive use of empirical and descriptive studies on the EU. To generate knowledge on how theory relates to the EU, two seemingly different theories are compared. Neorealism and social constructivism are used to generate hypotheses, which are then tested on a quantitive study on the EU’s Common Foreign and Security Policy. The study covers the years of 2003-2005 and uses a statistical method to present to empirical findings, which is supplemented by previous studies on EU’s foreign policy. The theoretical framework enables comparison of the two employed theories’ explanatory powers. The essay concludes that none of the theories provides satisfactory explanations of in regard to EU’s global power and/or influence. Nevertheless, they are able to explain different aspects of the developments of EU’s foreign policy. Further theoretical studies should be undertaken in order to highlight the issues of theory vis-à-vis the European Union.