Building on past research, this paper focuses on how previous victimization experiences, sympathy with a political party, and other social factors influence safety feelings at nighttime in public places in Germany. Using the micro-level theories from vulnerability and victimology, the study conducts an ordinal logistic regression analysis on data from a cross-sectional study conducted in 2019 on internal security in Germany commissioned by the German Federal Press and Information Office. Findings reveal that only some victimization experiences have a predicting impact on feelings of unsafety, namely harassment, online fraud, and theft have a significant effect. Further, the study showed that only sympathy for one party in Germany, the Alternative for Germany, has a significant predicting effect on fear of crime compared to not voting. Further gender differences were detected as females have a higher probability of feeling unsafe at night in public places.